Cabinet Refacing vs. Replacement: Which Is Right for Your Kitchen?

Cabinet Refacing vs. Replacement: Which Is Right for Your Kitchen?

One of the first decisions Fort Lauderdale homeowners face when planning a kitchen remodel is whether to reface their existing cabinets or replace them entirely. While both options can dramatically transform your kitchen’s appearance, the right choice depends on your layout, budget, and long-term goals.

At Italvave, we help homeowners every day weigh these two options. Below, we’ll walk you through the pros and cons of each, what’s trending in South Florida kitchens, and how to decide which solution makes the most sense for your space.

Cabinet Refacing and Replacement

What Is Cabinet Refacing?

Cabinet refacing involves keeping your existing cabinet boxes (the internal structure) and replacing only the exterior surfaces—such as the doors, drawer fronts, and visible panels. You can also update the hardware and hinges during this process for a refreshed look.

This approach is ideal when your cabinet layout works well, and the boxes are still in good condition. It’s like giving your kitchen a facelift without the time, cost, and disruption of a full renovation.

What Is Cabinet Replacement?

Cabinet replacement means removing your old cabinets entirely and installing brand-new ones. This gives you complete freedom to redesign your layout, upgrade materials, and incorporate modern hardware systems that increase storage and functionality.

Replacement is a better fit when you’re making structural changes, want to optimize your layout, or your cabinets are outdated or damaged beyond salvage.

Curious about what new cabinetry could look like in your space? Explore options on our kitchen remodeling page.

The Pros and Cons of Refacing in Fort Lauderdale

Pros of Cabinet Refacing:

  • Cost-Effective: Typically 30-50% less than full replacement

  • Faster Turnaround: Projects can be completed in just a few days

  • Minimal Disruption: No need to remove countertops or reconfigure plumbing

  • Eco-Friendly: Less waste and fewer materials

Cons of Cabinet Refacing:

  • Limited Layout Changes: You’re stuck with your existing cabinet configuration

  • Structural Wear Not Addressed: Weak or warped boxes remain

  • Doesn’t Add Storage: No internal upgrades unless added separately

Refacing is a great option if you love your current kitchen’s layout and just want a fresh, updated look with new faces and finishes.

The Pros and Cons of Cabinet Replacement in Fort Lauderdale

Pros of Cabinet Replacement:

  • Complete Design Freedom: Change your layout, add islands, extend cabinetry, or include custom features

  • Maximize Storage: Add deep drawers, pull-outs, lazy susans, or specialty inserts

  • Improved Durability: Start fresh with high-quality, long-lasting materials

  • Adds Long-Term Value: A fully remodeled kitchen is a major resale advantage in South Florida homes

Cons of Cabinet Replacement:

  • Higher Upfront Cost: Especially with custom cabinetry

  • Longer Timeline: Includes design, fabrication, and professional installation

  • May Require Permits: Especially when modifying plumbing, electrical, or layout

Looking for full-service remodeling with local expertise? Our kitchen contractors handle everything from permitting to final installation, ensuring a smooth experience start to finish.

Which Option Is Better for You?

Here are a few questions to help guide your decision:

  • Are your current cabinets still sturdy and functional?

  • Do you want to keep your existing kitchen layout?

  • Is your priority speed and budget, or long-term value and customization?

  • Are you planning to sell your home soon, or live in it long-term?

If you’re unsure, we recommend scheduling a consultation so we can inspect your cabinets and provide honest recommendations. Often, we’ll recommend refacing for homes with newer construction or solid cabinet boxes—and replacement for older homes or those undergoing full renovations.

Cabinet Finish Trends in Fort Lauderdale

Whether you're refacing or replacing, choosing the right finish can make a huge impact. Here’s what’s trending in 2025:

  • Textured Woodgrains: Earthy, tactile laminates from Tafisa and Wilsonart

  • Glossy European Slab Fronts: Popular for modern kitchens with clean lines

  • Matte Neutrals: Soft greys, whites, and taupes for timeless elegance

  • Bold Contrasts: Two-tone cabinets in black and natural oak

We carry premium finishes from trusted partners like Rehau, StyleLite, Prism, and more. Browse our selection on the cabinet hardware page to see the full range of materials and styles available.

Need Help Deciding? Visit Italvave’s Showroom

Our Fort Lauderdale showroom is the perfect place to see the difference between refaced and fully replaced cabinets. You’ll get to compare doors, finishes, and hardware in person—while getting expert advice from our team on what makes sense for your space.

We’ll walk you through:

  • Finish and material comparisons

  • Layout considerations

  • Cost and timeline planning

  • Fort Lauderdale code and permit needs

📍 Schedule a visit or drop by to get started on your kitchen transformation.

Get a Custom Estimate Today

Already have measurements or an idea of what you want? Use our online form to submit your kitchen dimensions, and we’ll prepare a custom estimate with options for both refacing and replacement. There’s no pressure—just honest guidance and beautiful results.

At Italvave, we’re committed to helping you make the best choice for your kitchen and your lifestyle. Whether you’re keeping the bones or starting fresh, we’re here to build something extraordinary.

Fort Lauderdale Showroom

751 W Oakland Park Blvd
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33311

786-559-1795

sales@italvave.com

Open M-F 10AM-5PM